- Home
- IELTS
- Writing Task 2
- Supervised homework time
IELTS Writing Task 2 · Advantages and disadvantages essay
Supervised homework time: model answer
Argue that supervised study is better when used for part of homework, not all of it. Focus on teacher support, fairness for students with difficult home conditions, and the manageable risks of fatigue and reduced independence.
The question
A advantages and disadvantages question on education. In the test, spend about 40 minutes on Task 2 and write at least 250 words. Task 2 counts twice as much as Task 1 in your Writing band.
Plan it in five minutes
- 1Decide that advantages outweigh drawbacks only if supervised study is limited and well managed.
- 2Choose two benefits: timely teacher support and fairer conditions for pupils’ home study.
- 3Add realistic examples, such as algebra help, science reports, shared rooms and siblings.
- 4Order paragraphs as introduction, two benefits, balanced disadvantages, and clear final judgement.
Model answer
Some schools are moving part of pupils’ homework into supervised study sessions before they go home. Although this may reduce family time and suit some learners less well, I believe the benefits are stronger because it improves support, fairness and study habits.
The main advantage is that students can complete difficult tasks while help is available. At home, a child who is stuck on algebra or essay planning may give up or copy a classmate. In a supervised period, a teacher can ask guiding questions, check understanding and correct misconceptions immediately. For example, a Year 9 pupil preparing a science report could learn how to organise data before writing the final version. This makes homework more useful for learning, rather than just a matter of compliance.
Supervised study can also make schoolwork fairer. Many pupils share a room, care for younger siblings, or lack a quiet desk after school. Keeping some academic work on campus gives them a calmer environment and reduces pressure on parents who may not know the subject or the language of instruction. Finishing work earlier can also protect evenings for rest, sport and conversation.
There are, however, disadvantages. A longer school day can be tiring, especially for younger children or those who travel far. It may also weaken independent study if supervisors give too much direction. These risks are real, but they can be managed by limiting sessions to selected days, allowing choice of tasks and training staff to support rather than spoon-feed.
Overall, replacing part of traditional homework with supervised study is a sensible reform when it is not excessive. Its advantages outweigh its drawbacks because it provides timely help, narrows home-based inequalities and can leave pupils with more balanced evenings.
286 words. Use it for ideas, structure and vocabulary rather than copying it: the question in your test will be worded differently, and an answer that does not respond to the exact question loses marks for Task Response.
Why this answer works
- Task ResponseThe answer gives a clear judgement through phrases such as “the benefits are stronger” and, in the conclusion, “Its advantages outweigh its drawbacks”. It also addresses both sides by acknowledging that “These risks are real” before explaining why they are manageable.
- Coherence and CohesionIdeas progress logically from support to fairness, then drawbacks. Linking is natural through phrases such as “The main advantage” and “There are, however, disadvantages”.
- Lexical ResourceThe essay uses topic-specific language accurately, such as “correct misconceptions immediately”, “calmer environment” and “spoon-feed”, without making the style unnatural or overly informal.
- Grammatical Range and AccuracyThe response shows varied sentence control, with concession in “Although this may reduce family time” and conditional meaning in “when it is not excessive”.
Useful vocabulary
| Phrase | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| supervised study period | Time at school for completing work with adult support. | A supervised study period can help pupils finish complex tasks calmly. |
| timely feedback | Advice given soon enough to improve learning. | Timely feedback prevents small errors from becoming repeated habits. |
| quiet learning environment | A calm place where students can concentrate. | Some children do better in a quiet learning environment after lessons. |
| independent study skills | The ability to work without constant help. | Schools should still build independent study skills through reading tasks. |
| reduce parental pressure | Make parents less responsible for homework help. | Supervised sessions can reduce parental pressure in families with limited time. |
| manageable drawbacks | Problems that can be controlled with good planning. | Longer days have manageable drawbacks if schools keep sessions short. |
Common mistakes on this question
- Writing only about homework generally and ignoring supervised study periods weakens the response.
- Claiming children need no homework at all does not answer the balanced comparison.
- Using vague examples about technology or tuition can distract from the school-based policy.
Write your own answer and get a band
Paste this question and your essay into Bandify's free writing checker. You get an estimated band for each of the four criteria in about ten seconds, with no account.