Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. IELTS
  3. Writing Task 2
  4. Grandparents as carers

IELTS Writing Task 2 · Discussion essay

Grandparents as carers: model answer

Discuss both sides by separating emotional family care from structured educational care. Give a balanced opinion: grandparents are excellent for affection and continuity, but quality childcare offers stronger social interaction and planned learning as children grow.

The question

Some people think grandparents are the best people to help raise young children, while others believe professional childcare gives children better social and learning opportunities. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

A discussion question on family. In the test, spend about 40 minutes on Task 2 and write at least 250 words. Task 2 counts twice as much as Task 1 in your Writing band.

Plan it in five minutes

  1. 1Decide a balanced view: grandparents support emotions, childcare leads learning after infancy.
  2. 2List two strengths and one limitation for each childcare option.
  3. 3Choose realistic examples: home language with grandparents, nursery sharing and routines.
  4. 4Order paragraphs as introduction, grandparents, professional childcare, opinion, concise conclusion.

Model answer

Parents often disagree about whether grandparents or trained childcare workers are better placed to look after young children. In my view, grandparents offer valuable emotional security, but professional childcare usually gives broader social and learning experiences, especially after infancy.

Grandparents are attractive carers because they already love the child and understand the family’s values. A grandfather who speaks the home language, for example, can teach songs, stories and respectful behaviour while giving patient one-to-one attention. This familiar care may suit babies and toddlers, who need trust and predictable routines. It can also reduce costs for parents. However, grandparents may struggle with active play, first aid, or current advice on nutrition and screen use, so their experience is not always enough.

Professional childcare offers strengths that relatives cannot easily provide at home. Trained staff can organise age-appropriate activities, watch development carefully and encourage children to mix with peers. In a nursery, a four-year-old may learn to share toys, wait for a turn, follow simple instructions and join group songs before starting school. These habits build confidence and independence. Centres also provide books, art materials and outdoor equipment. The main risk is quality: if staff are poorly trained or overloaded, children may receive less warmth and individual attention.

My opinion is that families should not treat this as an either-or choice. Once children are ready to interact beyond the home, a good childcare programme should provide the main daytime routine. Grandparents can then collect the child, tell stories and offer calm family time. This gives children structured learning without losing a secure family bond.

In conclusion, grandparents provide love, continuity and cultural connection, while professional childcare develops social skills and early learning more systematically. I therefore favour combining both, with the balance changing as the child grows.

295 words. Use it for ideas, structure and vocabulary rather than copying it: the question in your test will be worded differently, and an answer that does not respond to the exact question loses marks for Task Response.

Why this answer works

  • Task Response
    The answer discusses both positions and gives a clear balanced view through “valuable emotional security” and “broader social and learning experiences”, then develops the writer’s own solution in paragraph four.
  • Coherence and Cohesion
    Organisation is logical: separate paragraphs consider grandparents, centres, and the writer’s preference. Cohesion is helped by contrasts such as “However” and the practical sequence “Once children are ready”.
  • Lexical Resource
    Topic vocabulary is precise, including “age-appropriate activities”, “current advice on nutrition” and “structured learning”. These phrases discuss care, development and education without sounding memorised.
  • Grammatical Range and Accuracy
    The essay uses varied complex forms, such as “whether grandparents or trained childcare workers” and “if staff are poorly trained or overloaded”, while maintaining clear sentence control.

Useful vocabulary

Useful phrases for this question: Grandparents as carers
PhraseMeaningExample
emotional securitya feeling of safety and comfortGrandparents often give emotional security when parents work long hours.
age-appropriate activitiestasks suitable for a child’s ageGood nurseries plan age-appropriate activities instead of simply keeping children busy.
mix with peersspend time with children of similar ageChildcare helps shy children mix with peers through play and group tasks.
predictable routinesregular habits children can expectBabies feel calmer when carers follow predictable routines each day.
individual attentioncare focused on one child’s needsSome children learn faster when adults provide individual attention during activities.
secure family bonda strong, safe family relationshipRegular time with grandparents can strengthen a secure family bond.

Common mistakes on this question

  • Many learners describe only grandparents and forget the learning opportunities in childcare.
  • Some essays give an opinion in the conclusion only, making the position unclear.
  • Using extreme claims about family care or nurseries weakens the discussion.

Write your own answer and get a band

Paste this question and your essay into Bandify's free writing checker. You get an estimated band for each of the four criteria in about ten seconds, with no account.